Washington, DC 04:14 AM

What Comes Next in Israel's Elections?

Israel's electoral system gives smaller parties outsized influence over who becomes prime minister, and the answer may not be clear for weeks after Tuesday's vote.

Read in العربية
· 4 min read
إسرائيلي يهودي من الحريديم يختار ورقة الاقتراع في يوم الانتخابات العامة الإسرائيلية، داخل مركز اقتراع في القدس، 1 نوفمبر 2022. رويترز
An Ultra-Orthodox Jewish Israeli selects his ballot paper on the day of Israel's general election in a polling station in Jerusalem November 1, 2022. REUTERS/Ronen Zvulun TPX IMAGES OF THE DAY

Israelis began voting in Knesset elections today, with an opposition alliance seeking to oust longtime Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, under a complex electoral system where even a small political party can play a pivotal role in determining the shape of the next government.

The vote, the first since Hamas’ Oct. 7, 2023, attack on Israel, is seen by many as a battle for the country’s future. The opposition bloc unites parties from across Israel’s political spectrum that have joined forces to end Netanyahu’s combined 19 years in power. Former military chief Gadi Eisenkot is seen as its likeliest candidate for prime minister.

Exit polls are expected when voting closes at 10 p.m. local time, and ballots will be counted overnight. But under Israel’s electoral system, it could be weeks before it is clear who will lead the country.

How Voting Works

In Israel, voters do not elect the prime minister directly. Instead, they elect members of Israel’s 120-seat Knesset, or parliament, by voting for party lists, rather than by electing individual lawmakers in local constituencies.

In the country’s system of proportional representation, seats in parliament are allocated according to each list’s share of the vote. Elections are generally held every four years, although parliament can be dissolved and early elections called.

To win seats, a party list must clear the legally mandated electoral threshold of 3.25% of the vote, or roughly four seats. Votes for lists that fall short are not counted in the allocation of seats, which can shift the distribution for those that do get in. The electoral threshold was raised to its current level in March 2014, having been lower in previous years.

Why Things May Still Be Unclear After the Results

No party in Israel has ever won the 61-seat majority needed to govern on its own. So, governments are formed through coalitions of multiple parties. According to the latest polls, neither Netanyahu’s current ruling coalition nor the opposition has enough seats to form a government.

The opposition coalition is also yet to decide which of its party leaders would be its candidate for the premiership, and there is no guarantee that the alliance will continue to hold through negotiations to form a government.

Government formation could hinge on whether a slew of smaller parties make it past the 3.25% threshold to get into parliament, or on other alliances, such as with parties representing Arab Israelis. If the results are close, there could be a long period of political wrangling as Netanyahu or the opposition tries to win support from smaller parties.

This gives smaller parties considerable leverage over who becomes prime minister as well as how long the government remains in office. Prime ministers are often forced to accommodate the demands of smaller parties to keep their coalitions intact and remain in power.

How Is a Government Formed After the Election?

After the official results are announced, the president consults representatives of the elected parties and lists. Each parliamentary bloc recommends a Knesset member it considers suitable to form the government, according to official information on the presidency.

The law does not require the president to select the leader of the largest party. Instead, the president chooses the person deemed most likely to secure 61 seats in the Knesset through coalition agreements.

In practice, the leader of the party that wins the most seats is often given the first opportunity to form a government. But this is a political convention, not a constitutional requirement.

In 2009, for example, the centrist Kadima party won 28 seats to 27 for Netanyahu’s Likud. But then-President Shimon Peres tapped Netanyahu to form a government after a majority of lawmakers recommended him over Kadima leader Tzipi Livni.

The Israeli president gives the designated candidate 28 days to form a government, with the option of extending the deadline by up to 14 additional days, for a maximum of 42 days.

Once the designated candidate has secured sufficient parliamentary support, the candidate presents the government to the Knesset for a confidence vote.

If the candidate fails to form a government, the president may assign the task to another Knesset member, who is given 28 days without the possibility of an extension.

Together, those deadlines mean it could be more than two months before it is clear whether Netanyahu stays in power or the opposition alliance forms the next government.

Adapted and translated from the original Arabic.