Washington, DC 09:35 PM

40 Years On, Israel Still Seeks Answers About Missing Pilot

Israel pursued the theory that Iran was involved in the disappearance of its pilot Ron Arad, kidnapping and killing Iranian officials in search of answers. But a new investigation shows some Israeli officials have long doubted Iran’s involvement.

Read in العربية
· 7 min read
صورة نشرتها القناة الأولى الإسرائيلية في 13 يوليو/تموز 2008 دون تحديد تاريخ التقاطها للطيار رون أراد، الذي فقد أثره بعد أن قفز من طائرته فوق لبنان عام 1986. رويترز

In December 1989, Tamar Arad stood at an international human rights conference in Paris, holding a photograph of her husband, Ron, and another of their young daughter, who was not yet 4. She was searching for a way to reach her husband, who had disappeared three years earlier after his aircraft went down in southern Lebanon.

But Tamar had brought more than photographs. She had also come with a story from the Israeli government: there was “incontrovertible evidence” her husband was still alive and that his captors had at some point transferred him to Iranian authorities.

“I think this is better, because Iran is a country we can negotiate with,” Tamar told The New York Times in an interview published on Dec. 17, 1989.

From that point on, Iran became the main destination of Israel’s search for the missing pilot.

But the theory that Iran knew about Arad’s whereabouts was used by Israeli officials as justification for harsh actions, according to a new investigation by The New York Times. For example, Israeli forces abducted, interrogated and then killed Iranian Gen. Alireza Asgari, who offered no information on Arad, two decades ago, the Times reported.

But the theory was never universally accepted within Israel’s security establishment, according to accounts from former officials who spoke to MBN. Some had questioned for years the intelligence on which it was based.

The theory of Iranian involvement in Arad’s disappearance “was not based on genuine and sufficient intelligence,” Rami Igra, the former head of the Mossad’s Prisoners and Missing Persons Division, told MBN.

Igra said his doubts stemmed from negotiations between Israel and Iran, mediated by Germany in 1996 and 1997.

“Their reactions, the way they handled the matter and their behavior indicated that they had no role in it,” he said.

Igra said he raised his concerns while working at the Mossad in 1997 but received little support because his position ran counter to the prevailing belief at the time.

But Igra was not alone in his doubts.

Assessments within Israel’s security establishment were divided between those who believed Arad had been transferred to Iran and those who thought the search should remain focused on Lebanon.

“The Mossad adopted the first assessment and believed Arad was in Iran, while the Shin Bet and the Israeli military’s intelligence directorate adopted the second, concluding that he was in Lebanon,” said Yaron Blum, a former coordinator for prisoners and missing persons at the Israeli prime minister’s office.

Blum stressed that the possibility that Arad had not been transferred to Iran did not necessarily rule out an Iranian role in the case.

Gabi Siboni, a reserve colonel and security expert at the Jerusalem Institute for Strategy and Security, rejected criticism of the Mossad for maintaining its assessment that Arad was in Iran.

Siboni said intelligence agencies examine all possible scenarios before focusing on a particular line of inquiry. They continue to test their assumptions and may change the direction of an investigation when new evidence emerges or when the search reaches a dead end, he told MBN.

Differences in assessments among security agencies, he added, “are necessary.”

“Each agency examines the case from its own perspective, and by bringing all this information together, a broader intelligence picture emerges,” Siboni said.

Evidence That Failed to Resolve His Fate

The case began on Oct. 16, 1986, when a bomb released by an Israeli Phantom fighter jet exploded prematurely over southern Lebanon. Arad, then 28, ejected from the damaged aircraft but was captured by members of the Amal Movement, a Lebanese Shiite militia. Mustafa Dirani, the group’s security chief, took charge of him.

As efforts to locate Arad stalled, the account of an Iranian doctor in 1992 strengthened the theory that he had been transferred to Iran. The doctor claimed to have treated the pilot in both Iran and Lebanon. But the Mossad was unable to verify his account, and the doctor disappeared after being offered a financial reward in exchange for proving his claims, the New York Times reported.

In 1994, Israel abducted Dirani and brought him to Israel for questioning. He said Arad had been held in a house in the town of Nabi Chit, in Lebanon’s Bekaa Valley, and that his guards discovered he was missing after they left the house.

Dirani also recounted that an Iranian official had told him the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps, which the United States designates as a terrorist organization, had transferred the pilot to a camp inside Iran. But this account did not establish that Arad had been taken there, the newspaper reported.

Igra told MBN that he had been looking for another explanation for the mystery surrounding the missing Israeli pilot. He said Arad may have escaped his captors and died along the way or may have been killed by someone.

He also pointed to DNA tests conducted on remains that former Hezbollah Secretary-General Hassan Nasrallah sent to Israel after the 2006 Lebanon war. The tests failed to establish that the remains belonged to Arad. Hezbollah is an Iranian-aligned political party and armed group designated by the United States as a terrorist organization.

According to The New York Times investigation, subsequent Israeli intelligence reviews concluded that the information linking Arad to Iran was “unreliable.” In 2006, a Shin Bet review found that reports of his transfer to Iran “were based on false information or inaccurate interpretations.”

In 2016, Avi Kalo, the officer who headed the Israeli military’s Missing Persons Unit, concluded that Arad had not been in Iran. He described what had happened as “collective blindness” and recommended refocusing the search in Lebanon.

The Search Returns to Lebanon

In 2004, Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps joined Hezbollah in a joint search for Arad. According to The New York Times, the findings indicated that he had died in 1988 in the town of Nabi Chit and may have been buried there or nearby. But the information did not put an end to Israeli suspicions about Iran’s role.

In March 2026, Israeli forces returned to the town in search of his remains but failed to find him.

Blum told MBN that Israel had continued searching for Arad over the decades through military operations, negotiations and various intelligence channels. He said the prime ministers and political leaders he worked with during his tenure, from 2017 to 2022, remained committed to the case.

“That commitment remains in place despite Israel’s preoccupation with multiple security issues across seven fronts,” he said. “This is encouraging and shows that Israel never abandons its missing.”

The search continues along other lines, including through the case of Ahmed Shukr, a retired Lebanese security officer whom Israel suspects knew Arad’s whereabouts.

Shukr disappeared in December 2025. Lebanese officials believe he was abducted by Israeli agents. Israel says its leading theory is that Arad was executed in retaliation for the killing of Shukr’s brother in 1988. But Rana Shukr, a relative of Ahmed Shukr, denies that he had any connection to the case, according to The New York Times.

Ehud Eilam, a national security specialist and former researcher at Israel’s Defense Ministry, said the continued search for Arad has taken on added significance amid the ongoing military actions.

“If an Israeli aircraft carrying Israeli soldiers were to crash because of a technical malfunction during an escalation with Hezbollah in Lebanon or with Iran, Israel would do everything necessary to find out what happened,” Eilam told MBN.

He said this was something Israel wanted to make clear, particularly if Iran tried to withhold details as part of psychological warfare or had no interest in providing information or returning remains as part of a deal.

Forty years later, one of the theories that guided Israel’s search efforts for decades remains in doubt. The man Israel spent years looking for in Iran may never have left Lebanon at all.

Adapted and translated from the original Arabic.