Washington, DC 01:13 PM
My Mother Versus the IMF

MBN Magazine · November 2026

My Mother Versus the IMF

The humiliation of being forced to ask for what is already yours.

Joumana Haddad

Joumana Haddad is a Lebanese author, journalist, and activist.

· 6 min read

I recently managed to persuade the bank holding my 80-year-old mother’s life savings to release a small amount so she could undergo an operation that Lebanon’s deteriorating social security system would not cover. When the agent finally told me that management had agreed, relief overwhelmed me. I thanked him. And I thanked him again.

Then, in the middle of thanking him, it occurred to me: This was her money. She had not applied for a donation. (Banks restricted withdrawals after the financial crisis that began in 2019, leaving depositors like her unable to access their savings freely.) The bank’s management had not collected funds among themselves to help an unfortunate stranger. They had simply agreed to return a little of what they were withholding from her. They were allowing an elderly woman to spend a fraction of her own money on her own health. And I was thanking them as though they had offered to pay for the operation themselves. I felt humiliated, as I always do when forced to ask for what is already mine.

Recognizing this did not cancel the relief, though. My mother needed the operation. The money was necessary. The bank could have said no. I could understand the obscenity of the arrangement, feel frustrated because of it, and still be glad that, on this occasion at least, it had worked in our favor. That is what makes such power so indecent. It does not require you to believe in its legitimacy or its justice. It only needs you to need something badly enough.

I thought about this while reading about the IMF’s November mission to Lebanon. The Fund and the Lebanese authorities made some progress in talks on how to restructure the banks, how much depositors could recover, and who should bear the losses. They did not, however, reach an agreement on a restructuring plan. I understand that restoring a banking system is complicated. What I find harder to understand is how the people waiting for their savings are supposed to keep accommodating complexity. How much longer must my mother lend the system the years it has already borrowed from her?

What troubles me is when it is unnecessary in theory and compulsory in practice.

Those discussing who will absorb the losses are also deciding who can afford to fall ill. I would like them to keep an 80-year-old woman in the room, even if only in their imagination. Her body does not have the same timetable as a restructuring strategy. She saved partly so that illness would not leave her dependent on anyone, in a country where old age too often means relying on your savings or your children. Now she has both the savings and the dependence, a contradiction that only a corrupt banking system like ours could have achieved.

What happened with my mother exposes something larger than the bank, or her particular situation. In Lebanon, there are so many occasions on which obtaining what is yours feels like having persuaded someone to be kind and generous. A document, a public service, access to treatment, the completion of a procedure: Before asking what you are entitled to, you learn to ask yourself whom you know. Someone makes a call. Someone mentions a name. The obstacle moves, and you emerge relieved, carrying a debt of gratitude for something that was already yours.

I would like, for once, to receive something this country owes me without being expected to thank my good fortune or someone “influential” for arranging it. I am not campaigning against gratitude. What troubles me is when it is unnecessary in theory and compulsory in practice. You force yourself to be pleasant with the person who can help you, although the thing they might obtain for you was never theirs to give. Soon you hear yourself saying, “Without them, I would never have managed.” You may even be correct. That does not make them the solution. It just tells you how deeply your state and its institutions are failing you.

I keep wondering what would become of all these indispensable intermediaries if a citizen could just walk into an office or open an app and obtain what was due without invoking a name. A politician would then have to persuade you, because he could no longer count on your dependence. As things stand now, he only needs you to worry about what refusing him might cost the next time you need help. We often speak of clientelism as though it were a defect in the citizen’s character: a fondness for connections, a failure to respect procedure, an unwillingness to wait one’s turn. Sometimes it is. But many people may also be choosing between the indignity of asking and going without something they cannot afford to lose.

The person accepting assistance is not necessarily surrendering a conviction. They may be trying to keep a child in school, obtain medicine, or get through the month. Yet the arrangement can impose a political claim on them regardless. No politician has to purchase a vote outright in order to compromise the freedom with which it is cast. What freedom do you have to oppose someone today when you may need his intervention to obtain your rights tomorrow?

The politician who makes us plead can become remarkably accomplished at pleading himself. Before a powerful foreign government, he discovers the indignity of waiting for approval, the obligation to sound grateful, the difficulty of refusing someone whose assistance he needs. You might expect the experience to make him less willing to inflict it on others. Instead, when he returns home, something of the humiliation travels down with him, until it reaches those with nobody beneath them. Dependence abroad becomes another excuse for domination at home. The citizen must understand the leader’s constraints; the leader need not understand the citizen’s.

We, the Lebanese citizens, are, and have long been, the creditors of this country.

I know that an agreement with the IMF cannot return every deposit to the Lebanese people overnight. But surely we can ask it to begin restoring something besides confidence in banks: the possibility of approaching them without rehearsing how desperate, how patient, how grateful we must sound. Otherwise, even when some money comes back, we will still be waiting for permission to feel it is ours.

I think again of the agent who told me the bank’s management had agreed. I do not know what effort he made on our behalf, and I am not interested in turning him into the villain of a system he does not command. My thanks may well have been deserved by him personally. But his willingness to help should never have been so decisive. My mother’s access to her savings should not have depended on whether I could persuade a particular person to carry her need upstairs. At 80, a woman should not have to qualify as a sufficiently compelling case to use the money she spent a lifetime saving.

We, the Lebanese citizens, are, and have long been, the creditors of this country. Why are we the ones paying its debts?

The views expressed in this article are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect MBN’s editorial stance.